How to incorporate conflicting opinions?

Home Forums Thoughts About Participatory Modeling How to incorporate conflicting opinions?

This topic contains 3 replies, has 3 voices, and was last updated by David Crookall David Crookall 1 year, 1 month ago.

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #630
    Emily Bondank
    Emily Bondank
    Participant

    When there are conflicting opinions on the underlying dynamics of the model, would the solution be to create different models for the different opinions?

    #631
    Emily Bondank
    Emily Bondank
    Participant

    Steven Gray just said at the Participatory Modeling Field School 2019 (paraphrased) — EMBRACE THE DIVERSITY. Plot out the separate conflicting models and show the diversity of knowledge and ways of thinking. Then think about the cultural agreement regarding the topic. It could spark important conversations that could move decision making forward.

    #633
    Alexey Voinov
    Alexey Voinov
    Keymaster

    Isn’t it going to depend upon the nature of the conflict? Are we really talking about entirely conflicting models, or maybe the conflict is about a few variables, or processes, or parameters? Maybe the differences are not that dramatically serious, and you could simply run some sensitivity tests to see how far the differences will take us.

    #680
    David Crookall
    David Crookall
    Participant

    Maybe:
    Most situations that we attempt to model are conflictual in some way.
    So it may be useful to distinguish between:

    system conflicts: conflicts in the system that we are modelling and that are thus incorporated as part of the process of mapping ‘reality’ into a model – the system conflict is represented in the model

    modelling or model conflicts: conflicts that designers, stakeholders, modellers, et al develop among themselves regarding any given model or set of models, and thus could concern the represented ‘reality’, the process of mapping, the design of the model, etc

    of course, the second type of conflict may arise over the first type — do we then have a conflict of conflicts? 🙂

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.